Do you agree that studying historical fiction just like the Silver Pigs is a greater way of learning about history than history lessons?

In this essay I am going to say the advantages and drawbacks of both Historical Fiction and Mr Drew’s History lessons. Historical fiction is a real story written however altered to make it extra attention-grabbing. Some examples of historical fiction are Silver Pigs and Troy.

Don’t waste time Get a verified expert to help you with Essay

Silver Pigs is a criminal offense novel by Lindsey Davis. It was set in Rome and Britannia throughout AD 70. The main character is Marcus Didius Falco who helps rescue a girl from a pair of thugs.

When she dies he decides to get involved and to attempt to find her murderer. But this leads him to go to Britannia and to go underneath cover within the mines.

Some individuals could say that reading historical fiction is better than historical past lessons. In some methods I do agree with this because you wouldn’t get homework, it would be extra attention-grabbing and extra atmospheres, you’ll be able to learn any where and as it’s extra attention-grabbing you’ll bear in mind extra.

For example we learn a passage from the silver pigs and I keep in thoughts that they used scorching turnip mash to cure chilblains. Also courses are at a set time so you can’t stop them if you like and typically you may not need to learn all of the things you would possibly be informed.

However others may say that history classes are higher than historic fiction. When you’re in class the teacher is there to help when a pupil doesn’t understand something and to show us in a method during which we are in a position to understand.

For instance we were given an exercise to do which concerned drawing a hippo in a crate. This was to assist us keep in mind Hippocrates and all the issues that he believed in, like observation and the Hippocratic Oath. Unlike lessons historical fiction could not all be true. Many of the writers may exaggerate for effect and to make it more fascinating. he e-book could not have an index so that you can find the particular info you could need or any photos to refer the information you’ve read to. Also in lessons we go in to extra depth into the particular data that we have to learn and are able to share our ideas in regards to the work with our teacher and our peers, to get a better understanding of the topic and put the data to practice.

Having examined the arguments I really feel that probably the most helpful technique for learning history is in history lessons as a end result of there we’re capable of get help and solely be taught the knowledge that we really need for our exams. People who maybe study higher when reading text, studying from another person’s viewpoint, or are learning historical past for a complete totally different reason could find Historical Fiction a greater learning method.